Abstract
Generative artificial intelligence complicates a longstanding assumption in higher education assessment: that the quality of a finished artifact provides sufficient evidence of learning. This article reframes the challenge posed by generative AI as a problem of assessment validity: what observable evidence warrants claims about what students know, understand, and can do? Drawing on construct validity, learning theory, assessment-for-learning, and evaluative judgment scholarship, the article proposes an AI-Responsive Assessment Framework for broadening the evidentiary basis of assessment. Four interlocking principles—judgment-centered tasks, process visibility, metacognitive transparency, and iterative human feedback—elicit complementary evidence of students’ intellectual activity alongside finished products. Rather than replacing product with process assessment, the framework supports more defensible inferences about learning through multiple forms of evidence aligned with the construct being assessed. This reframing locates rigor in disciplinary judgment and conceptualizes academic integrity as intellectual accountability for decisions embodied in AI-mediated work.
Publisher
South Dakota State University
Rights
© 2026 The Authors
Recommended Citation
Bayraktar, Breana, "Beyond AI-Proofing: Rethinking What Counts as Evidence of Learning" (2026). The Interdisciplinary Journal for Research on Pedagogy and Learning Design, Vol. 1, Issue 1., Fall 2026. 6.
https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/ijrpld/6
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License