Abstract
As artificial intelligence tools increasingly support pedagogical practices, higher education institutions face pressing questions about bias, transparency, student trust, and relational dimensions of pedagogy. While considerable attention has focused on student use of generative AI, less attention has been given to the ethical implications of faculty use of AI in assessment. Further, many sources promote the idea of ethical considerations, but few actually offer specific guidance. This article presents a practice-based analysis of structured ethical deliberation around AI-assisted grading at a public Hispanic-Serving Institution. Drawing from discussions conducted through a newly established AI Ethics Board, including listening sessions with faculty, students, staff, and administrators, the analysis documents how stakeholders articulate concerns and conditions for responsible implementation. The article surfaces ethical considerations to guide equitable, transparent, and relationally grounded use of AI in assessment, and offers a transferable protocol and an adaptable institutional model for ethical inquiry into and guidance toward AI in teaching and learning.
Publisher
South Dakota State University
Rights
© 2026 The Authors
Recommended Citation
Flores, Cynthia; Benedetti-Coomber, Jeff; Rae, Dani; and Gonzalez, Lorna, "Assessment as Relationship: Ethical Conditions for AI-Assisted Grading in Higher Education" (2026). The Interdisciplinary Journal for Research on Pedagogy and Learning Design, Vol. 1, Issue 1., Fall 2026. 22.
https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/ijrpld/22
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License